Making Peace under socialism: a polemic against “monopoly”

“

In journalism, there has always been a tension between getting it first and getting it right.      

Ellen Goodman

Here’s why researchers say breathing San Francisco air today is like smoking 11 cigarettes SFGate

Enemies pursue Soros in Germany Handelsblatt

Malta police identify suspected journalist murder masterminds – report

Caruana Galizia, who penned an anti-corruption blog, was killed by a car bomb near the Maltese capital Valletta in October 2017.

• Did East German women have more orgasms than those in the west? How market forces affect sexuality
• Sex under socialism
• 
  

• Chill factor: people in cold climates drink more alcohol

  Researchers found evidence that climate contributed to a higher incidence of binge drinking and liver disease.
  
  
  
  

• Sydney man allegedly filmed more than a dozen tenants, possessed 50 videos

  Police allege a 49-year-old man covertly filmed numerous residents living in two apartments he manages on Bunn St in Pyrmont.
  
  
• 
  

• Oskar Rabin, Painter Who Defied And Critiqued The Soviet State, Has Died At 90

  
  In 1974, Rabin organized a show of dissident artists that was broken up by dump trucks and bulldozers - and that caused an international backlash. "In 1978 officials encouraged him to make a trip to Paris; while he was there they stripped him of his citizenship. He lived in Paris the rest of his life, even though he became celebrated in Russia after the fall of the Soviet Union." … [Read More]

 The Sex Recession -  Kate Julian at The Atlantic:

Gen Xers and Baby Boomers may also be having less sex today than previous generations did at the same age. From the late 1990s to 2014, Twenge found, drawing on data from the General Social Survey, the average adult went from having sex 62 times a year to 54 times. A given person might not notice this decrease, but nationally, it adds up to a lot of missing sex. Twenge recently took a look at the latest General Social Survey data, from 2016, and told me that in the two years following her study, sexual frequency fell even further.

• 
  
• Francis of Assisi’s life in poetry will stay in the mind forever | The Spectator

Heatwaves can ‘wipe out’ male insect fertility Guardian

• 
  
  The Current Affairs Field Guide To Socialist Animals Current Affairs
  
  
  
  
  
• Literature v. fiction
• 
  

• Exploring The Intellectual Dark Web (How Far Will It Go?)

  
  Over the past year, the IDW has arisen as a puzzling political force, made up of thinkers who support “Enlightenment values” and accuse the left of setting dangerously illiberal limits on acceptable thought. The IDW has defined itself mainly by diving into third-rail topics like the genetics of gender and racial difference—territory that seems even more fraught in the era of #MeToo and the Trump resistance. …Read More
• Can former political staffers turn into impartial public servants?
  A better system is needed to acknowledge experience in a ministerial office to enable public servants to transfer back at a higher level and non-public servant staffers to have their service recognised in the APS.

• Who are the staffers shaping our political landscape?

  Victoria Draudins
  The ministerial office is one of the last largely inscrutable parts of our democracy. Where do these staffers come from, and what makes them qualified? A researcher is only now building a picture.

  Evidence-based policymaking still a travesty

  Nicholas Gruen
  Evidence-based policy ... if everyone claims to want it, and practice it, why do so many projects get glowing evaluations without the slightest tinkering?

• Before replacing a carer with a robot, we need to assess pros and cons

  Helen Dickinson & Catherine Smith
  It's easy to get excited about the potential for robots to help care for the sick, injured and elderly, but we need the right regulations in place to deal with issues as they emerge.
  
  
  
  
  
  

  Words that should be banned from government writing

  
  

  Dr Neil James

  When it comes to language, we all have our pet peeves: words that are overused, misused, or just plain abused. But should we go a step further and ban the worst offenders?
  

  Writing: five ways to get your brief read by the minister

  Chris Savage

  Your minister has a choice: the in-flight magazine or your policy brief. How do you get read? Make life easy for them in how you present the information.
  
  
  

  
  

  Tim Wu, in a recent NYT Op-Ed, presents a polemic against “monopoly”:
  
  

  
  

  Postwar observers like Senator Harley M. Kilgore of West Virginia argued that the German economic structure, which was dominated by monopolies and cartels, was essential to Hitler’s consolidation of power. Germany at the time, Mr. Kilgore explained, “built up a great series of industrial monopolies in steel, rubber, coal and other materials. The monopolies soon got control of Germany, brought Hitler to power and forced virtually the whole world into war.”

  
  

  To suggest that any one cause accounted for the rise of fascism goes too far, for the Great Depression, anti-Semitism, the fear of communism and weak political institutions were also to blame. But as writers like Diarmuid Jeffreys and Daniel Crane have detailed, extreme economic concentration does create conditions ripe for dictatorship.

  The first ten words are already a give-away, as is the beginning of the second cited paragraph.  For contrast, this is from Thomas Childers, well-known historian of Nazi Germany:
  
  

  
  

  In his biography of Henry Kissinger, historian Niall Ferguson notes that “old man Thyssen” — that is, German steel magnate Fritz Thyssen — “bankrolled Hitler.” Businessmen such as Thyssen using their financial assets to assist the Nazis was “the mechanism by which Hitler was funded to come to power,” according to John Loftus, a former U.S. attorney who prosecuted Nazi war criminals.

  
  

  But the Nazis were neither “financed” nor “bankrolled” by big corporate donors. During its rise to power, the Nazi Party did receive some money from corporate sources — including Thyssen and, briefly, industrialist Ernst von Borsig — but business leaders mostly remained at arm’s length. After all, Nazi economic policy was slippery: pro-business ideas swathed in socialist language. The party’s program, the Twenty-Five Points, called for the nationalization of corporations and trusts, revenue sharing, and the end of “interest slavery.”

  
  

  And Wu’s two other cited sources?  Both focus mainly on IG Farben.  Diarmuid Jeffreys is “an award-winning journalist and television producer with thirty years’ experience in the media industry.”  He does have a book on IG Farben and the making of the German war machine, but it does not demonstrate how economic concentration brings totalitarian regimes to power, instead focusing on how IG Farben profited from Nazi war aims and helped build the Holocaust.  Earlier in the 1930s, IG Farben had in fact resisted Nazification. though the company did jump on board once it saw Nazification as inevitable.

  
  

  Here is the Daniel Crane essay on antitrust and democracy.  Try this excerpt: “… it does not necessarily follow that Farben’s monopolistic position in the German chemical industry is causally related to the rise of fascism—or that monopoly enabled Nazism. Two matters should give us pause before making such an inference.”  Read p.14 to see what follows, but here is one tiny bit: “Though gigantic, Farben remained smaller than three American industrial concerns—General Motors, U.S. Steel, and Standard Oil. Nor was Farben’s wartime market power exceptional.”  On the other side of the ledger, Crane does note that fascistic governments, once in power, find it easier to take over and co-opt more highly concentrated industries, Farben being an example of that.  So there is an argument here, but mainly one data point and also some very serious qualifiers.

  
  

  Does that all justify the sentence “But as writers like Diarmuid Jeffreys and Daniel Crane have detailed, extreme economic concentration does create conditions ripe for dictatorship.”?  “Ripe” is such a tricky, non-causal word.

  
  

  I would instead stress that war, civil war, scapegoating, and deflation create the conditions “ripe for dictatorship.”  You might want to toss Russia and China into the regression equation, or how about Cuba and North Korea and Albania and Pol Pot’s Cambodia?  How would the coefficient on industrial concentration end up looking?  I’d like to know.

  
  

  When big business is the target, and tech in particular, the standards of proof for Op-Eds seem to decline.  Somehow, because we all know that the big tech companies are bad, or jeopardizing democracy, it is OK to make weakly argued claims.

  
  
  
  Incremental reform now, ‘real cultural change’ later: APS twin goals
  APS: While the APS Review panel works on a list of public recommendations to flesh out its five-point “vision” for the high-performance bureaucracy of 2030, its secretaries are privately working on their own plans for reform at the same time.
  
  Kennedy’s ‘secret list’ of questions to ask yourself during a briefing
  LEARNINGS: Steven Kennedy, one of Australia’s most senior public servants, reveals his ‘secret list’ of things to ask himself while being given a briefing by public servants.
  
  10 social impact lessons I learnt as a not-for-profit leader
  KRISTY MUIR: Leading social purpose organisations is hard, slow work that takes exceptional leadership, passion, patience and humility.
  
  
  Foster customer service champions
  PARTNER EVENT: The government conducts over 40 million transactions each year. Learn to optimise your service delivery and innovate your omni-channel strategy at The Government Customer Service Summit.
• 
  


BEPS Action 5: Resumption of application of substantial activities factor to no or only nominal tax jurisdictions  (16 Nov 2018)

What the Amazon tax breaks really mean  (16 Nov 2018)
Multi-millionaires pursued for suspected tax avoidance  (16 Nov 2018)
Tokyo struggles to adjust to latest 'tax haven': the US  (16 Nov 2018)

BBC accused of not untangling 'mess' over freelancers' tax  (15 Nov 2018)
The chances of seeing Donald Trump's tax returns just went WAY up  (15 Nov 2018)
US Multinationals Flee No-Tax Caribbean Havens, in Favor of Low Tax Havens (15 Nov 2018)
EU must confront Trump and approve a tax on tech giants like Facebook and Apple: French minister
   (15 Nov 2018)
Helipads and airport lounges: The perks cities offered for Amazon's HQ2  (15 Nov 2018)
EU states still divided over money laundering reform  (14 Nov 2018)
Danske Bank's $225 billion money-laundering scandal might be 'tip of the iceberg' of Russian wealth flowing into West
  (14 Nov 2018)

Student 'money mules' sentenced for money laundering  (14 Nov 2018)

Leaked documents show Kante refused to be paid in a tax haven  (14 Nov 2018)
Apple's world-beating financial engineering is teaching the corporate world how to exploit Trump's tax cuts
  (14 Nov 2018)

UK House of Commons Debate: Draft Double Taxation Relief and International Tax Enforcement (Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man) Order 2018 (14 Nov 2018)
Overhaul of UK's poor banking culture is slow, admits standards chair  (14 Nov 2018)
Italian prosecutors believe Recordati evaded 400 million euros in tax   (14 Nov 2018
Ex-UBS trader Kweku Adoboli has been deported  (14 Nov 2018)
IRS Criminal Investigation leveraging more data analytics  (14 Nov 2018)

The country's great tax conundrum  (14 Nov 2018)
'Dirty money' crackdown by UK banks hits 1m prospective customers  (14 Nov 2018)
HMRC tells people in tax debt to pay up by taking out commercial loans  (14 Nov 2018)

EU states back stronger money laundering monitoring of banks  (13 Nov 2018)

The tax man is watching: France to comb social media for cheats  (13 Nov 2018)
GAAR Advisory Panel opinion of 12 October 2018: employee rewards using loans (13 Nov 2018)

Jersey: Economic substance for companies - introduction to proposed legislation for economic substance (13 Nov 2018)

Key aspects in relation to proposed economic substance requirements, as issued by Guernsey, Isle of Man and Jersey  (13 Nov 2018)
Top Philippines news site and company chief face tax evasion charges  (13 Nov 2018)
Rappler CEO calls Philippine tax evasion charges 'intimidation'  (13 Nov 2018)