Friday, November 20, 2026

MONA has now cost David Walsh $503m, but he’s hopeful

 MONA has now cost David Walsh $503m, but he’s hopeful

David Walsh insists his Museum of Old and New Art will become profitable even as new documents reveal his lifetime losses from it have exceeded $500 million, as the professional gambler continues to ride his luck to prop up his passion project on the banks of the River Derwent.

Moorilla Estate Pty Ltd – the private company that owns MONA and other businesses in Walsh’s empire including Moorilla Estate winery, beer maker Moo Brew, Dark Mofo winter festival operator DarkLab and museum guide technology provider Art Processors – lost a net $46.9 million in 2025-26, according to its annual report lodged with the corporate regulator on Tuesday.

David Walsh and wife Kirsha Kaechele outside MONA in 2022. Amy Brown

The loss is an improvement on the $48 million shortfall recorded in 2024-25, and a $63 million loss the previous year, but still takes the total losses recorded by the company since Walsh opened MONA in 2011 to $503 million.

The string of losses raises questions about how long Walsh can continue to finance what has become a cornerstone of Tasmania’s tourism industry, with MONA attracting 358,000 visitors in 2025-26, and Dark Mofo another 115,988.

Of Moorilla’s $52 million revenue in 2025-26, just $7.4 million came from state government grants, most of it to support the festival. Total borrowings with Commonwealth Bank increased by $7 million to $56 million.


Walsh, however, remains confident the finances will turn around, with a proposal for a hotel on the site still in the works despite the last one faltering during the pandemic, and big hopes for growth in the Art Processors business.

“My intent is to have it profitable by the time I die – unless that’s next Tuesday,” Walsh said in an emailed statement.

It is MONA driving most of Moorilla’s losses. Walsh spent $75 million carving his subterranean museum into the sandstone cliffs of the Berriedale peninsula near his working-class childhood home at Glenorchy, but over the past few years has also spent $100 million on a library for his 30,000 books, which include a first-edition copy of Shakespeare’s First Folio worth $12 million, and David Bowie’s hand-written lyrics to Starman.

The new wing includes a chamber where oxygen is extracted from iron ore after being trapped since the Great Oxidation Event of 2 billion years ago, meaning visitors – one at a time – can inhale air never breathed by anyone else.

Such extravagance is paid for by Moorilla’s parent company, Downward Spiral Enterprises, which also lodged financials on Tuesday revealing a $45 million profit.

That came after a $41 million “capital contribution” to Moorilla, taking the total of such contributions – which are not reported as intercompany loans because Walsh expects no repayment – to almost $510 million.

Downward Spiral’s revenue of $155 million included a dividend of $103 million, and net assets of $334 million, sourced from Walsh’s luck as a gambler.

Gambling continues to pay off

With fellow University Of Tasmania dropout Zeljko Ranogajec, Walsh is behind one of the world’s biggest betting syndicates.

Its systems famously won it $63 million in a German lottery in 2022, and some members won a $150 million Texas lottery the following year after buying almost every ticket. Walsh said that contrary to reports, he was not among the latter group.

“I have been involved in a few lottery plays over the years – winners and losers – but almost all of what I do is racing and sports betting,” he said.

Walsh is trying to structure more self-reliance into Moorilla’s balance sheet in case his luck changes.

“We need to get a hotel at MONA,” he said, hinting at the revival of an ambition stalled in 2021, when a 176-room design by architects Fender Katsalidis – conceived as an inverted suspension bridge jutting out over the Derwent – stalled amid pandemic uncertainty and estimated costs blowing out past $400 million.

Walsh had considered bundling a hotel in with the library extension works, but decided against it.

“I separated the library to make the hotel a purely commercial proposition, so banks can use their metrics to fund it,” he said. No timeline on any new proposal was provided.

A growing share of Moorilla’s revenue was contributed by Walsh’s Art Processors start-up. It built the digital guide, audio tour, queueing system and various multimedia experiences for MONA, and has since worked with the likes of Sydney Opera House, Australian War Memorial, Los Angeles’ J. Paul Getty Museum and Tulsa’s Bob Dylan Centre.

It even dispensed with the Dewey decimal system for MONA’s library, allowing users to replace a book where they like because the shelves are automatically rephotographed and its location updated in the wayfinding system.

“I’m pretty confident the technology will be useful to bookshops, record stores et cetera,” said Walsh.

“In the long term, it will become a major funder of MONA.”

Walsh wants MONA to become sustainable, but he never intended to profit from it personally.

“I built MONA to absolve myself from feeling guilty about making money without making a mark,” he told The New Yorker in 2013.

The best of travel, fashion, cars and more, straight to your inbox. Sign up to our weekly newsletter.

 is The Australian Financial Review’s Arts & Culture editor, based in Sydney. You can send him encrypted tips on Signal at michaelb2203. Connect with Michael on Facebook and Twitter. Email Michael at m.bailey@nine.com.au

The Prophet of Putinism

 Hillary Clinton: What Trump Should Have Said to Putin

On Thursday in Shenzhen, China, President Trump met face-to-face with President Vladimir Putin of Russia and President Xi Jinping of China. A strong, strategic American president should have demanded that the Russian military stop bombarding Ukrainian civilians and destroying their energy and water infrastructure. He should have warned Mr. Xi that China will pay a price for providing support for Russia’s war machine. And he should have made it clear to Mr. Putin that his efforts to freeze the Ukrainian people into submission this winter will fail — because the Ukrainians are tougher than Mr. Putin thinks and because the United States and our NATO allies will redouble support to them.
No one expected Mr. Trump to do any of this. Initial reports suggest that he didn’t (Mr. Trump departed the summit without holding a news conference on his talks with Mr. Putin).
On Monday, he once again made excuses for Russia, claiming that Mr. Putin “could be a lot tougher” on Ukraine. Instead of confronting Russia’s strategy to create a humanitarian crisis in Ukraine this winter, the Trump administration seems to be aiding and abetting it.
Over recent months, the United States has actually reduced its support for Ukraine. The Pentagon reportedlyhas slowed deliveries of vital air-defense missiles. According to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukraine has suffered repeated disruptions to their access to Starshield (the military version of SpaceX’s Starlink), which among other things helps them shoot down attack drones, and to American early warning intelligence about incoming Russian missile strikes. On Tuesday, Mr. Zelensky said that Ukraine’s access to Starshield’s service remains limited...


The Prophet of Putinism 

Nov. 19, 2026

By Natasha Kiseleva
Ms. Kiseleva is a Russian writer based in 
Berlin and runs the Telegram channel 
Natasha Daily Against War.

There is a peculiar comfort in watching a bleak film about your country. You can enjoy the dark depiction of your homeland and then, at the end, you can tell yourself that the director is exaggerating, that things aren’t quite so bad, that your country isn’t like that. The experience affords the pleasures of both criticism and absolution.


For more than 20 years, that’s how I watched the films of Andrey Zvyagintsev, perhaps Russia’s foremost living director. I recognized his characters, admired his artistry and reveled in the frisson of seeing my country represented so unsparingly. Then I reassured myself that these were exceptional stories, not a realistic portrait of Russia.


“Minotaur,” Mr. Zvyagintsev’s new film, shows how wrong I was. With characteristic subtlety and hypnotic beauty, it tells the story of Gleb, a prosperous Russian businessman in a Russian town. In early 2022, he faces two crises: His wife is having an affair, and the authorities are demanding 14 men from his company for the war in Ukraine. The film follows his attempts to resolve both problems, personal and political. I won’t spoil it, but it’s safe to say that Gleb is no Samaritan.


With its title and plot, the film — Mr. Zvyagintsev’s first since the full invasion of Ukraine — invites viewers to see contemporary Russia in the terms of classical myth. But if Vladimir Putin is the Minotaur, demanding lives to feed his appetite for war, then Mr. Zvyagintsev is something of a Cassandra, the inspired seer whose warnings went tragically unheeded. For all the acclaim his work has won, Mr. Zvyagintsev is the ignored prophet of Putinism.


Mr. Zvyagintsev’s first film, “The Return,” carried ancient echoes, too. A father returns after 12 years away and takes his sons on a journey to a mysterious island. Issuing arbitrary demands, he offers neither affection nor explanation; his authority requires only obedience. Released in 2003, during Mr. Putin’s first term, the film generated mostly biblical interpretations, with the father figure resonant of Abraham. Its implicit warning about the political structure of Russian society went largely unnoticed.


With “The Banishment,” made four years later, Mr. Zvyagintsev took his study of coercive authority beyond the circle of children and into the married unit. A husband’s obsession with his wife’s presumed infidelity takes a terrible toll on those around him, as he gives in to paranoia. A fable of estrangement, misunderstanding and male control, the film dramatized a darkening atmosphere in Russia, increasingly beholden to Mr. Putin and wandering deeper into the Minotaur’s labyrinth.

A disturbing feature of Mr. Zvyagintsev’s characters is how rarely they recognize their own cruelty. They have reasons for doing terrible things, sometimes even rooted in love. In “Elena,” from 2011, a woman poisons her wealthy husband to secure an inheritance for her family. She commits murder for the sake of the people she loves, an understandable impulse if not an admirable act. Yet the trade-off between humanity and security, where feeling is perverted by material need, typified the moral numbness of post-crash Russia. 


By “Leviathan,” in 2014, private cruelty had acquired the machinery of the state. A corrupt mayor sets out to take the home of Nikolai, a mechanic who refuses to surrender what is his. Across an excruciating sequence, he is subjected to legal persecution, intimidation, character assassination and worse. The predatory nature of Russian politics was hard to miss: This was the year of Russia’s annexation of Crimea and the conflict in eastern Ukraine, as Mr. Putin — like the mayor — sought to assert his interests by any means necessary.


After the political exploration of “Leviathan,” Mr. Zvyagintsev returned to the domestic sphere. In the Oscar-nominated 2017 film “Loveless,” a boy overhears his divorcing parents arguing about who will take custody of him. Then he disappears. He had become invisible long before he vanished: If Elena killed for a child she loved, these parents barely notice theirs. By this point in time, violence no longer requires a villain — it is almost an effect of the system. This regression registers the depredations of the decade, in which Mr. Putin throttled the opposition and consolidated control.


Taken together, his first five films chart Russia’s descent across the 21st century. In their mostly domestic, small-town, oblique way, they show the rot of Putinism settling into Russian society. Mr. Zvyagintsev’s achievement is to make us feel what political analysis struggles to describe: the terrible ease with which cruelty, in a dehumanizing culture defined by the Kremlin, becomes ordinary. Yet despite their success, the films were generally seen as parables rather than what they were: portents of the darkness to come.


Now, after illness and in exile, Mr. Zvyagintsev is back with “Minotaur.” Here, indifference to the fate of others — a hallmark of all his films, heralding Russia’s turn to war — becomes a matter of accountancy. The 14 men demanded by the authorities recall the 14 young Athenians sent to the Minotaur in Greek myth. Some of my Russian friends call it Mr. Zvyagintsev’s first dead film: Its characters seem hollow, incapable of feeling. Yet I see that emptiness as a dramatic method, perhaps the only way to convey the suffocating atmosphere of contemporary Russia.


Nearly five years into the war in Ukraine, the world knows what it’s looking at now. But there is a curious parallel between the way the West watched Mr. Putin and the way we watched Mr. Zvyagintsev’s films. We watched Mr. Zvyagintsev’s films and mistook his gloominess for a metaphor. Western leaders watched Mr. Putin and mistook his threats for a negotiating position. In both cases, with horrified fascination, we assumed that things couldn’t be that bad. But the Minotaur was in the room all along, and Cassandra was right.


I left Russia in March 2022, but leaving a country and ceasing to consider it your own are different things. Even in exile, I could disagree with Mr. Zvyagintsev, my fellow foreign agent, and resist his bleak vision of Russia. But no matter what, I felt his films were always about us. Yet as the final credits of “Minotaur” rolled, I realized that this was no longer my country. For the first time, Mr. Zvyagintsev’s film was about them, other people in a land I could not recognize.

Source Photographs: MKProductions, CGCinema/Mubi; Kino Lorber
The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. We’d like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Here are some tips. And here’s our email: letters@nytimes.com.
Follow the New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Bluesky, WhatsApp and Threads.

SAMS Power Couple


  • John Sams. Appointed CEO of KPMG Australia in July 2026. He began his career in tax at KPMG UK in 2003 before relocating to Australia in 2006, later serving as KPMG Australia's CFO and COO. 
  • Michelle Sams. Promoted in November 2026 to Deputy Commissioner, Programs & Strategies at the Australian Taxation Office (ATO). Before joining the ATO in 2017, she worked as a Director in KPMG Australia's Deal Advisory Tax team and previously studied at the London School of Economics.


Hot off the Mandarin presses: Michelle Sams has been promoted to deputy commissioner, programs & strategies, at the Australian Taxation Office.


Almost three in ten big corporations didn't pay tax in 2023-24

ATO Assistant Commissioner Michelle Sams says there are legitimate reasons why some entities don’t pay tax


KPMG CEO John Sams makes key leadership appointments 

By Edmund Tadros 

 Nov 5, 2026 

KPMG Australia chief executive John Sams has appointed three senior partners to key leadership roles as the firm prepares to axe up to 400 staff to offset the fallout from its document misuse scandal and an extended ban on bidding for federal contracts.

Gayle Dickerson will take over as chief operating officer and chief financial officer, replacing Eileen Hoggett and Sams in those respective roles. Hoggett is suing KPMG after the firm dismissed her for sharing confidential Lendlease board documents to win audit contracts and repeatedly denying it.

Gayle Dickerson has been appointed chief operating officer and chief financial officer of KPMG Australia, while head of tax and legal Ben Travers will add the second role of deputy chief executive. Eamon Gallagher

Dickerson, who had been exploring external opportunities, has led the firm’s deal advisory and infrastructure business since July and previously led its turnaround and restructuring practice.

Head of tax and legal Ben Travers will take on the new role of deputy chief executive, and Jeff Cook will become chief risk officer. Senior partner Pete Turner replaces Dickerson as head of deal advisory and infrastructure.

Travers, a former leadership contender, has worked with Sams on managing the scandal since July. Cook was regional head of quality and risk management and a member of the global risk group.


Dickerson, tasked with leading the retrenchments, said that the role requires being “disciplined with our finances, honest about what’s working and what isn’t”.

Travers said he would focus on “bringing the best of the firm” to clients and developing “a culture built on trust and accountability” for partners and staff.

In an email to partners on Thursday afternoon, Sams said executive search firm Spencer Stuart assisted with the appointments.

“I appreciate that this more structured approach took some time and I’d like to thank you all for your patience,” Sams wrote.

Senior partner Pete Turner will replace Dickerson as head of deal advisory and infrastructure. Dickerson, Travers and Turner will take on the new roles immediately, while Cook will move into the chief risk officer role after handing over his regional responsibilities.

KPMG has been in crisis since March, when audit partners were accused of misusing confidential client data and leveraging conflicted relationships to win work.

The scandal worsened as the firm’s botched handling of the leak and the whistleblower prompted an exodus of clients, partners and staff.

Former chief executive Andrew Yates, former head of audit Julian McPherson and chairman Martin Sheppard all quit the firm after the scandal became public.

Find out the inside scoop about Accenture, Deloitte, EY, KPMG, PwC and McKinsey. Sign up to our weekly Professional Life newsletter.

 leads our coverage of the professional services sector. He is based in our Sydney newsroom.Email Edmund at edmundtadros@afr.com.au

KPMG Australia axes hundreds of jobs in latest corporate bloodbath