Sunday, July 20, 2003

Cherry picking Is nothing new under the sun?

Some critics are asking (properly attributing that phrase to the writer of Ecclesiastes in the Bible, of course). Author Joan Didion pointed out that when she arrived at college 'it was immediately impressed on me that all the novels necessary had already been written.' Does that suggest we're living in unimaginative times in which lazy artists simply mimic the past or, worse, slip into plagiarism? A quick scan of popular culture could suggest that.
· Wicked Witch of the West [Christian Science Monitor 07/18/03 ]
· They should know better [National Post 07/15/03]
It's got to the stage where some publishers offer you 'reading money' to read the book, and then put in the letter some phrase to the effect that 'of course the money isn't Intended to influence your judgment'.
· The generous giants [Telegraph (UK)]