Fitness culture champions such eating habits, but emerging research suggests consuming more than your body naturally craves could make you age faster.
Consumers are bombarded with advertising and promotions linking higher protein diets to better health, but a recent review published in the peer-reviewed journal Cell Press Blue suggests our obsession with the macronutrient could shorten our lives.
Drawing on more than 350 studies, the review found that recent recommendations to increase dietary protein intake were misguided because research showed high-protein diets were associated with accelerated ageing and increased risks of death and disease.
Protein restriction, by contrast, had a favourable effect on various biological processes linked to ageing.
Defined as reducing protein intake while maintaining overall energy intake, protein restriction led to better blood sugar control, fewer “zombie” or senescent cells that neither die nor divide, healthier mitochondria (the powerhouses of the cell), and a dampening down of ageing-related pathways, the review found.
But what does this mean for the average Australian?
Experts say health troubles are more likely when people regularly consume more protein than their bodies need, which is more likely when they consciously aim to eat more protein but do not exercise regularly.
Most Australians will get enough protein to satisfy their daily requirements simply by eating three healthy, balanced meals.
This is partly because of a natural inbuilt system that guides us towards consuming sufficient protein.
Dietary protein requirements are higher for older people, pregnant women, women in perimenopause, and other groups such as active individuals who train frequently.
But if your main goal is building or maintaining muscle, experts say that resistance training delivers about 85 per cent to 90 per cent of the stimulus required. Optimising your protein intake provides only an extra 10 per cent to 15 per cent.
And for most people, consciously aiming for a high-protein target can increase the risk of consuming more protein than their body needs, while making them less likely to achieve other important health goals, such as avoiding ultra-processed foods and eating enough fruit and vegetables.
The ‘proteinostat’
Nutritional biologist Stephen Simpson, a professor at the University of Sydney’s Charles Perkins Centre and School of Life and Environmental Sciences, says we do not have to overthink protein intake because humans have an inbuilt “proteinostat” that regulates it.
“When you need protein, you feel hungry for protein and savoury flavours, and when you don’t need protein, those flavours are not attractive to you,” says Simpson.
This inbuilt system helps us eat the right amount of protein relative to our needs without consciously aiming for a daily target.
Simpson says it presumably evolved because there are costs associated with eating both too much protein and too little. But ultra-processed foods can hijack the system.
When we need protein, our liver releases a hormone called fibroblast growth factor 21 (FGF21), which acts on our brain to make us crave protein flavours instead of sweet ones. This helps us address a protein shortage by encouraging us to seek out protein-dense foods.
But savoury snack foods can interfere with this process because, while they are low in protein and high in fats and carbohydrates, they taste like protein and can hijack our appetite when our liver releases FGF21.
“They are, quite literally, protein decoys,” says Simpson of these snacks. “You end up not satisfying your protein appetite but eating a bunch of calories.”
When we eat these low-protein, calorie-dense foods, we typically end up consuming excess calories because of something called the protein leverage hypothesis.
The protein leverage hypothesis, developed by Simpson and his University of Sydney colleague David Raubenheimer, states that humans will naturally prioritise the consumption of protein over other dietary components, and will keep eating until their protein needs have been met, regardless of how many calories they end up consuming.
“You need to eat more to get the protein that you didn’t get [from the ultra-processed savoury snacks], and so away you go, and you end up eating more calories,” Simpson says.
The hypothesis also helps explain why high-protein diets can aid weight loss. Our biological drive to keep eating drops once protein requirements are satisfied, which can help people lose weight if this occurs before they have consumed enough total calories to balance their energy expenditure.
The risk of eating too much protein
What’s good for weight loss is not necessarily good for healthy ageing in normal-weight individuals, though.
The Cell Press Blue review found that restricting dietary protein intake positively affected a range of biological processes linked to ageing.
“The biology of ageing involves a whole series of different metabolic processes, and restricting protein does delay some of those, while elevated protein or higher-than-required protein does accelerate those same processes,” says Simpson.
What constitutes “high-protein” is relative to a person’s life stage and activity level, rather than a fixed universal number.
“That’s entirely well-founded in preclinical models: flies, mice, worms, and essentially any [animal model] that people have looked at.”
In one study, cutting protein intake from about 20 per cent of overall energy intake to about 8 per cent made rats live for about 40 per cent longer. In another, dropping protein from 21 per cent to 12.6 per cent extended the rats’ lifespan by 52.7 per cent.
But whether these studies translate to humans is hotly contested.
While Simpson acknowledges there are no randomised controlled trials proving that dietary protein restriction extends human lifespans, he notes that biomarkers of ageing are elevated in humans on high-protein diets, and large population studies have linked high intakes to increased risks of death and disease.
These facts appear to support the notion that high-protein diets, relative to a person’s needs, accelerate ageing.
But observational links cannot prove causation. In the real world, a high-protein diet often comes with confounding factors, such as excess saturated fat from processed meats or a lack of fresh fruits, vegetables, and fibre, which may be the true culprits behind the disease risk.
Andy Philp, head of the Healthy Ageing Research program at the University of Technology Sydney, is also cautious about overstating the applicability of preclinical studies to the real world because the animals used live in an artificial bubble.
Unlike humans, caged rodents never face the threat of infection, food scarcity or tasks requiring strength. They are given a tightly controlled diet and monitored to see how long they live.
“The consequence of living longer in that scenario is probably that you’re smaller and weaker, but that’s the trade-off to be able to live longer,” says Philp.
He says lifting weights and other forms of resistance training are the key drivers of muscle growth and maintenance – not protein intake. “The protein gives you another 10 per cent to 15 per cent on top,” he says. “Just eating protein on its own is not going to do anything near that.”
How much protein you should eat
The federal government’s nutrient reference values suggest adult men require 0.84 grams of protein a kilogram of body weight each day and women 0.75 grams. For those aged 70 and over, these values rise to 1.07 grams and 0.94 grams respectively.
Simpson says these figures are probably at the lower end of what is healthy.
The sweet spot for the general population, he says, is likely to be closer to 15 per cent of total energy intake from protein. However, he says we do not need to consciously strive for this target because we will hit it naturally if we tune in to our bodily cues.
What’s more, the CSIRO’s Protein for Weight Loss report found that the average protein intake for Australian adults was closer to 19 per cent of total energy intake, suggesting most Australians are already getting enough.
Where greater attention is often needed is in active individuals and older people.
“If you’re a woman during perimenopause, your protein requirements go up also because you lose protein as part of the process of hormonal changes around menopause,” says Simpson.
The Australian Institute of Sport says athletes and others committed to daily exercise need more protein than the general population to repair and build muscle broken down during exercise.
Specifically, it recommends aiming for a target in the range of 1.2 to 1.6 grams of protein a kilogram of body weight each day, or more for those trying to lose weight.
“[That] is a good range to start with. But it [depends on] total body mass, energy requirements, and the amount and type of training,” says Louise Burke, a sports dietitian and professor at Australian Catholic University.
Work by Stuart Phillips, a professor in the Department of Kinesiology at McMaster University in Canada, suggests that muscle gains max out at 1.6 grams of protein a kilogram of body weight each day when combined with resistance training; once you go beyond that, more protein doesn’t build more muscle or strength.
Older people have greater protein requirements because of age-related anabolic resistance, which describes the reduced ability of ageing muscles to build and repair in response to dietary protein and resistance exercise.
“Your muscle gets less sensitive [to these stimuli] as you age, so you need more protein [to build muscle],” says Philp.
“But we seem to eat less protein as we age for a number of reasons. So, you get a double whammy: you’re not getting enough protein, and your system is desensitised to the stimulus.”
The Cell Press Blue review also stated that restricting dietary protein could be harmful for pregnant women, growing children, those eating a restricted number of calories and those recovering from injuries.
What about people on GLP-1s?
One group who may be unable to rely on their natural bodily cues to ensure they get enough protein are people taking GLP-1 drugs such as Ozempic, Mounjaro or Wegovy.
“That’s what we’re testing at the moment,” says Simpson.
Simpson’s hypothesis is that the GLP-1s may block the protein appetite signal triggered by the protein hunger hormone FGF21 but leave intact the hormone’s suppression of sweet cravings.
“So, you end up eating neither protein nor carbohydrates; hence you don’t eat much,” Simpson says. “Your calorie intake goes down, you lose weight, but you also lose lean mass.”
If this hypothesis is validated, the advice would be for people to consciously ensure they consume enough protein rather than relying on natural cues, while also doing resistance training to offset the loss of lean muscle mass.