Interim leader of the Opposition, Angus Taylor, claims NDIS funding can be cut further by limiting benefits to Australian citizens only, but he can’t say by how much. Claudia Weisenberger with the facts.
“If you’re not an Australian citizen, then you do not get the privileges of an Australian citizen.”
That was Opposition Leader Angus Taylor in May, announcing a plan to strip non-citizens — including permanent residents — of access to the NDIS and 17 other welfare programs.
This week, Taylor reiterated that rhetoric in The Australian on Monday 16 November, keeping the claim alive in the pre-election debate. The plan, he has said, would save “many billions” over the forward estimates.
Six months on, the number behind that claim remains a mystery.
MWM contacted the Parliamentary Budget Office to ask whether it had ever modelled the cost of NDIS supports provided to non-citizen participants. The PBO replied on 16 November: “The PBO has not published analysis of the NDIS provided for non-citizens.”
The PBO’s response carried a significant caveat. Under its own legislation, work commissioned by parliamentarians can be kept strictly confidential — made public only if the requesting parliamentarian chooses to release it. In other words, a costing may exist. It may simply never have been released.
Taylor’s office was asked the same question — what is the Coalition’s actual estimate, and what data or modelling underpins it? No response was received.
In the absence of any publicly available costing, Taylor has repeatedly cited the total NDIS budget — $53B for the current financial year, covering all 774,000 participants. That figure represents the full cost of the scheme for every participant regardless of citizenship status.
However, under current rules, the NDIS is already largely closed to new arrivals. Access requires Australian citizenship, permanent residency, or a protected special category visa — a narrow category covering mainly long-term New Zealand residents. Temporary migrants are already excluded.
The pool of non-citizens drawing on the scheme is very small by design.
An ambit claim
When Taylor was pressed on what a person who suffered a life-changing injury while working towards citizenship would do if the NDIS was unavailable, his answer was blunt: “At the end of the day they can become a citizen.”
It is not that simple. Becoming a citizen takes a minimum of four years from the date of permanent residency and is not free. For hundreds of thousands of permanent residents in Australia, it is not possible at all — not because they are unwilling, but because their country of origin does not permit dual nationality.
Countries that do not permit dual citizenshipinclude India, China, Malaysia, Singapore, Indonesia, Japan and South Korea, which constitute some of Australia’s largest permanent resident communities. For a person from any of those countries, becoming an Australian citizen means permanently surrendering their original nationality.
The personal and legal consequences of surrendering that citizenship are significant and vary by country, but they are rarely trivial.
Taylor’s answer assumes that citizenship is simply a form to fill in. For a significant proportion of the people his policy targets, it is an
irreversible act with serious consequences.
Grandfathering
Taylor has said that existing non-citizen NDIS participants would be grandfathered — meaning they would keep their current supports.
But grandfathering is not a guarantee. NDIS plans are regularly reviewed and adjusted, and thousands of Australians have already lost supports under Labor’s tightening of eligibility. A non-citizen participant whose plan comes up for review under a Coalition government would have no certainty their support would continue.
The Coalition has not explained whether grandfathered participants would be subject to the same review rules as citizens, or different ones.
Australia would also be moving against the grain of comparable countries.
In the UK, permanent residents with settled status are eligible for Personal Independence Payment, the UK’s main disability support. In Canada, permanent residents can access the Registered Disability Savings Plan. New Zealand extends disability support to permanent residents under its own scheme.
The logic in those countries is straightforward: permanent residents pay taxes, contribute to the economy, and are on a legal pathway to full citizenship. Excluding them from disability support is not presented as a fiscal saving — it is recognised as a policy choice to
withdraw the safety net from people who have already committed to the country.
Devil in the (hidden) details
Taylor’s announcement contained a second measure that largely went unreported: a 10-year residency requirement for the age pension and the disability support pension — not just for non-citizens, but even for migrants who do become Australian citizens.
Under this proposal, a person who arrives in Australia, takes out citizenship after the minimum four years, and then suffers a serious disability would still be locked out of the disability support pension until they reach the 10-year mark.
Citizenship, in other words, is not the finish line Taylor presents it as. It is one hurdle of several.
Settlement Services International (SSI) chief executive Violet Roumeliotis said the plan would leave permanent residents “excluded from accessing the very supports they help fund.” She noted that permanent residents already wait up to four years for many social security payments, making further exclusion both unnecessary and disproportionate.
Health Minister Mark Butler was more direct. Speaking on ABC Radio National on 15 May 2026, he argued that Taylor’s plan would leave permanent residents who had lived, worked and paid taxes in Australia for years without support — people who, in his words, would be told,
if you fall down the stairs and become a quadriplegic, you’re on your own.
He also accused Taylor of “huffing and puffing on the dog whistle that he borrowed from One Nation,” warning that “trying to out One Nation Hanson is never going to work.”
No data, no policy
Without knowing how many non-citizens are on the NDIS and what their plans cost, it’s impossible to know what the savings would be.
Taylor has promised to release detailed costings “closer to the election”. That is not a timetable. It is a placeholder for a number that may not exist in the form he has implied, using a big number of $53B to make a political point.
Claudia Weisenberger is a management consultant with deep experience in pharmaceuticals, hospital transformations, and strategic due diligence across four continents. She combines sharp analysis with hands-on execution.