Accountants Daily : Tax Commissioner granted access to protected documents in defamation defence
Tax Office Commissioner wins access to secret tax documents
The head of the Australian Taxation Office has won a court case against his employer to access secret documents that he will use to fight a defamation battle against a former tax agent.
Commissioner of Taxation Chris Jordan sought the documents to defend the claim brought by Vanda Gould, whose registration to practice was terminated after he was excoriated in a Federal Court judgment for "disgraceful" conduct.
Mr Gould brought a defamation case against Mr Jordan over remarks the Commissioner made at the National Press Club in 2017 about Project Wickenby, the Tax Office's offshore tax avoidance probe that led to the pursuit of celebrities such as Paul Hogan.
At the club, Mr Jordan gave the example of "this Hua Wang Bank case" as among those tackled by the project.
"It involved one promoter with over $350 million we’ve collected," Mr Jordan said. "They formed this Samoan bank and did all these transactions to hide profits. And you have the principal of that scheme appearing before the House of Reps committee on tax disputes, giving evidence and being cited, saying how difficult and awful ...
Protected information could be disclosed for defamation proceedings
The Federal Court has confirmed that protected information the ATO held relating to the affairs of a taxpayer may be disclosed by a taxation officer for the purpose of the defamation proceedings the taxpayer commenced against the Commissioner.
The court found that such a disclosure would be in the performance of the taxation officer's duties, by reason that the disclosure would be for the purpose of civil proceedings related to a taxation law.
FC of T v Second Commissioner of Taxation & Anor 2019 ATC 20-712, [2019] FCA 1602, White J, 27 September 2019.
A long-running legal battle between Tax Commissioner Chris Jordan and once-high-profile Sydney accountant Vanda Gould continues, with the Federal Court granting Mr Jordan access to confidential information about Mr Gould and his associates.
Key points:
- Tax Commissioner Chris Jordan has been granted access by the Federal Court to protected taxpayer information
- The information relates to former Sydney accountant Vanda Gould, who has mounted defamation proceedings against Mr Jordan
- The documents Mr Jordan is seeking for his defamation defence include audit material about Mr Gould and his associates
Protected information could be disclosed for defamation proceedings
The Federal Court has confirmed that protected information the ATO held relating to the affairs of a taxpayer may be disclosed by a taxation officer for the purpose of the defamation proceedings the taxpayer commenced against the Commissioner.
The court found that such a disclosure would be in the performance of the taxation officer's duties, by reason that the disclosure would be for the purpose of civil proceedings related to a taxation law.
FC of T v Second Commissioner of Taxation & Anor 2019 ATC 20-712, [2019] FCA 1602, White J, 27 September 2019.