Hillary Clinton: What Trump Should Have Said to Putin
There is a peculiar comfort in watching a bleak film about your country. You can enjoy the dark depiction of your homeland and then, at the end, you can tell yourself that the director is exaggerating, that things aren’t quite so bad, that your country isn’t like that. The experience affords the pleasures of both criticism and absolution.
For more than 20 years, that’s how I watched the films of Andrey Zvyagintsev, perhaps Russia’s foremost living director. I recognized his characters, admired his artistry and reveled in the frisson of seeing my country represented so unsparingly. Then I reassured myself that these were exceptional stories, not a realistic portrait of Russia.
“Minotaur,” Mr. Zvyagintsev’s new film, shows how wrong I was. With characteristic subtlety and hypnotic beauty, it tells the story of Gleb, a prosperous Russian businessman in a Russian town. In early 2022, he faces two crises: His wife is having an affair, and the authorities are demanding 14 men from his company for the war in Ukraine. The film follows his attempts to resolve both problems, personal and political. I won’t spoil it, but it’s safe to say that Gleb is no Samaritan.
With its title and plot, the film — Mr. Zvyagintsev’s first since the full invasion of Ukraine — invites viewers to see contemporary Russia in the terms of classical myth. But if Vladimir Putin is the Minotaur, demanding lives to feed his appetite for war, then Mr. Zvyagintsev is something of a Cassandra, the inspired seer whose warnings went tragically unheeded. For all the acclaim his work has won, Mr. Zvyagintsev is the ignored prophet of Putinism.
Mr. Zvyagintsev’s first film, “The Return,” carried ancient echoes, too. A father returns after 12 years away and takes his sons on a journey to a mysterious island. Issuing arbitrary demands, he offers neither affection nor explanation; his authority requires only obedience. Released in 2003, during Mr. Putin’s first term, the film generated mostly biblical interpretations, with the father figure resonant of Abraham. Its implicit warning about the political structure of Russian society went largely unnoticed.
With “The Banishment,” made four years later, Mr. Zvyagintsev took his study of coercive authority beyond the circle of children and into the married unit. A husband’s obsession with his wife’s presumed infidelity takes a terrible toll on those around him, as he gives in to paranoia. A fable of estrangement, misunderstanding and male control, the film dramatized a darkening atmosphere in Russia, increasingly beholden to Mr. Putin and wandering deeper into the Minotaur’s labyrinth.
A disturbing feature of Mr. Zvyagintsev’s characters is how rarely they recognize their own cruelty. They have reasons for doing terrible things, sometimes even rooted in love. In “Elena,” from 2011, a woman poisons her wealthy husband to secure an inheritance for her family. She commits murder for the sake of the people she loves, an understandable impulse if not an admirable act. Yet the trade-off between humanity and security, where feeling is perverted by material need, typified the moral numbness of post-crash Russia.
By “Leviathan,” in 2014, private cruelty had acquired the machinery of the state. A corrupt mayor sets out to take the home of Nikolai, a mechanic who refuses to surrender what is his. Across an excruciating sequence, he is subjected to legal persecution, intimidation, character assassination and worse. The predatory nature of Russian politics was hard to miss: This was the year of Russia’s annexation of Crimea and the conflict in eastern Ukraine, as Mr. Putin — like the mayor — sought to assert his interests by any means necessary.
After the political exploration of “Leviathan,” Mr. Zvyagintsev returned to the domestic sphere. In the Oscar-nominated 2017 film “Loveless,” a boy overhears his divorcing parents arguing about who will take custody of him. Then he disappears. He had become invisible long before he vanished: If Elena killed for a child she loved, these parents barely notice theirs. By this point in time, violence no longer requires a villain — it is almost an effect of the system. This regression registers the depredations of the decade, in which Mr. Putin throttled the opposition and consolidated control.
Taken together, his first five films chart Russia’s descent across the 21st century. In their mostly domestic, small-town, oblique way, they show the rot of Putinism settling into Russian society. Mr. Zvyagintsev’s achievement is to make us feel what political analysis struggles to describe: the terrible ease with which cruelty, in a dehumanizing culture defined by the Kremlin, becomes ordinary. Yet despite their success, the films were generally seen as parables rather than what they were: portents of the darkness to come.
Now, after illness and in exile, Mr. Zvyagintsev is back with “Minotaur.” Here, indifference to the fate of others — a hallmark of all his films, heralding Russia’s turn to war — becomes a matter of accountancy. The 14 men demanded by the authorities recall the 14 young Athenians sent to the Minotaur in Greek myth. Some of my Russian friends call it Mr. Zvyagintsev’s first dead film: Its characters seem hollow, incapable of feeling. Yet I see that emptiness as a dramatic method, perhaps the only way to convey the suffocating atmosphere of contemporary Russia.
Nearly five years into the war in Ukraine, the world knows what it’s looking at now. But there is a curious parallel between the way the West watched Mr. Putin and the way we watched Mr. Zvyagintsev’s films. We watched Mr. Zvyagintsev’s films and mistook his gloominess for a metaphor. Western leaders watched Mr. Putin and mistook his threats for a negotiating position. In both cases, with horrified fascination, we assumed that things couldn’t be that bad. But the Minotaur was in the room all along, and Cassandra was right.
I left Russia in March 2022, but leaving a country and ceasing to consider it your own are different things. Even in exile, I could disagree with Mr. Zvyagintsev, my fellow foreign agent, and resist his bleak vision of Russia. But no matter what, I felt his films were always about us. Yet as the final credits of “Minotaur” rolled, I realized that this was no longer my country. For the first time, Mr. Zvyagintsev’s film was about them, other people in a land I could not recognize.
- Discreet Relationship and a Surprising Discovery
- Ruminating Again? Here’s How to Stop.
- Dave DeWitt Has Died. He Was the Patron Saint of Fiery Foods.


