‘Voracious, greedy, lying scoundrels’: Politicians united on PwC
Politicians from all major parties have accused PwC of a “calculated breach of trust” by covering up and attempting to minimise the seriousness of the tax leak scandal and urged the accounting giant to co-operate fully with all investigations.
In a joint report, Coalition, Labor and Greens senators said PwC engaged in unethical behaviour, first by claiming legal professional privilege over tens of thousands of documents, and then through failing to report a serious breach of confidentiality despite having a legal obligation to do so.
“This document reveals a profoundly unethical nature of behaviour inside the organisation over many, many years, and it is indeed a calculated breach of trust,” the report said.
The PwC scandal came to light earlier this year when it was revealed that a Tax Practitioners Board investigation found PwC’s former Australian head of international tax, Peter Collins, had made unauthorised disclosures of confidential information about government plans to combat multinational tax avoidance.
A few months later, it emerged that more than 50 PwC staff, including in the company’s overseas operations, were either directly involved or had knowledge of the leak.
RELATED ARTICLE
Greens senator Barbara Pocock said PwC partners signed confidentiality agreements and then aggressively sold the government information they gained to clients, earning millions in fees.
“They were voracious, greedy, lying scoundrels, and they thought they could get away with it – and they probably would have, without alert journalists and an alert Senate,” she said in the Senate on Wednesday evening.
The committee report made two recommendations: That PwC co-operate fully with all investigations into the matter, and that the firm be open and honest with Australians, parliament and the international community by publishing detailed information about the PwC personnel involved.
Committee chair, Liberal senator Richard Colbeck, said the committee wanted to be careful now a criminal investigation was under way, but its report was deliberate.
“This is not just a calculated breach of trust, but it’s an egregious one,” he said.
Finance secretary Jenny Wilkinson says the department was kept in the dark over the extent of the breaches of confidentiality by staff at PWC.
Colbeck said PwC did not seem to understand that it had a responsibility to provide appropriate information to authorities and the community about the scandal.
“It’s time that they co-operated with the investigations that are being undertaken so that we can understand what went on, and the Australian community deserves to understand what went on,” he said.
“They should be open and honest with the Australian people, the international community, and accurately publish information about who was involved.”
Colbeck acknowledged the work of Pocock and Labor senator Deborah O’Neill in helping to bring the scandal to light.
The fallout escalated in late May when the Federal Police confirmed it had launched a criminal investigation into the leak.
The next day, Finance Department secretary Jenny Wilkinson lashed the firm’s failure to disclose the full extent of the leak and revealed the department had in effect banned PwC from taking on future federal government contracts until the matter was satisfactorily resolved.
PwC’s acting head, Kristin Stubbins, apologised the following week, and admitted the culture within the company had “allowed for profit to be placed over purpose”.
“[It] is clear, in hindsight, that PwC Australia did too little, too late,” she said.
The firm stood down nine partners pending the outcome of its own investigation, and a week after the apology and handed over the names of more than 60 current or former staff and partners who were included on emails related to the scandal after repeated calls from senators.
But those actions have failed to allay the concerns of some existing and potential customers. Earlier this month, AustralianSuper froze all future work with PwC and said it was reviewing its ongoing auditing work with the firm, an action later followed by other major super fundsincluding Aware Super and CareSuper.
Construction giant Lend Lease iced plans to hire PwC as its auditor, while Reserve Bank governor Philip Lowe said PwC would have to prove it had changed if it wanted to gain work from the bank in future.
PwC engaged in ‘multi-year cover up’ over tax leaks: Senate
PwC Australia engaged in a deliberate multi-year strategy to cover up the breach of confidentiality in the tax leaks scandal, as company personnel worked to monetise the information, a scathing parliament report has found.
Senator Deborah O’Neill during a Senate estimates. Alex Ellinghausen
A furious Senate committee on Wednesday night accused the big four firm of obfuscation, intimidation and an unwillingness to give full and frank explanations over the leak of internal Treasury advice.
The report, titled A calculated breach of trust, demands that PwC “co-operate fully and openly with all investigations and inquiries including by the Australian Federal Police and the Tax Practitioners Board” and that the firm publish “accurate and detailed information about the involvement of PwC partners and personnel, including their names and positions.”
In an unusual move, the committee, chaired by Liberal senator Richard Colbeck, jointly published the report while the inquiry was ongoing.
Labor’s Deborah O’Neill, a committee member who helped reveal the extent of the leaks, said the report “lays bare the egregious breach of public trust and commonwealth security” by PwC.
“It shocks me that the obfuscation by PwC Australia continues and that PwC Global appears to be attempting to walk away from this profound ethical failure and calculated breach of trust,” Senator O’Neill said.
Greens senator Barbara Pocock said the report shows the firm was taking a “go-slow” approach to responding to the scandal.
Greens senator Barbara Pocock slammed PwC over the tax leaks saga. Alex Ellinghausen
“The committee unanimously agrees that PwC should come clean and fully co-operate with independent inquiries into their wrongdoing. PwC must move beyond a simple ‘fall guy’ strategy’,” Senator Pocock said.
“[The] evidence cited in this report shows an internal culture at PwC so poor that it has lost the capacity to act honestly. In fact, it is clear now that its senior leadership does not recognise basic ethical and legal principles. The evidence also creates a strong argument for breaking the link between political donations and big consultancies.”
A spokesman for PwC said the firm would “carefully consider” the report.
“We have taken swift steps to improve the governance, culture and accountability within the firm, and we will not hesitate to take all appropriate actions necessary to re-earn the trust of our stakeholders,” he said.
More to come.
