Pages

▼

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Ben Howell : Former Chubb insurance boss alleges fraudulent accounting

Former Chubb insurance boss alleges fraudulent accounting 

By Max Mason

The former Australian boss of New York-listed Chubb has accused the insurance giant, its management and directors of allowing fraudulent accounting practices and claims he was sacked after he raised concerns that it was causing misleading financial results.

Ben Howell, who was Chubb’s Australia and New Zealand president for two years until October, filed a claim against the company and 11 of its directors and executives last month in the Federal Court.

Former Chubb Australia and New Zealand country head Ben Howell claims his sacking came in retaliation for raising accounting concerns. LinkedIn 

Chubb is one of the world’s largest insurance companies and is listed on the New York Stock Exchange. In Australia, it offers commercial, property, casualty, accident and business travel insurance, and is a major sponsor of the Australian Open tennis tournament.

Howell first worked for Chubb as an underwriting manager from 2002 to 2005. He returned in 2016 and held numerous roles across the Asia-Pacific region until getting the top job in Australia and New Zealand.

In his statement of claim, Howell alleged that Chubb employed a practice of misreporting revenue so that senior executives, including his predecessor and regional bosses, could hit business targets and maximise bonuses and promotion potential.


He alleged that the practice, called “calendarisation”, involved written premiums not being recognised as revenue on the day they became enforceable. Instead, Chubb would only recognise the revenue when it processed the terms through its internal systems, he claims.

“As a consequence, employees of Chubb could (and did) control when valid and enforceable agreements were processed through Chubb’s internal systems in order to manipulate intentionally the timing of written premium revenue recognition (revenue timing), usually into a subsequent financial reporting quarter or year,” Howell’s statement of claim alleged.

Ben Howell alleges staff were instructed not to mention the revenue practice to Chubb chief executive Evan Greenberg. AP

During an Asia-Pacific leadership meeting in Singapore in April 2025, Howell claimed that he mentioned how calendarisation was impacting growth results.

He alleged that in 2025 the timing of revenue in previous years made 2025 appear lower than 2024, “a year in which the growth reported in Chubb’s financial records far exceeded the true business growth”.

“Staff were instructed not to refer to the impact of calendarisation when explaining financial results, including to [Chubb Limited chief executive] Evan Greenberg.”

Howell claimed that he raised the issue with the former regional president for Asia-Pacific, Paul McNamee, who allegedly said, “I never want to talk about calendarisation again” and “that is your cross to bear”.

A Chubb spokeswoman said the company takes all claims seriously and denies Howell’s allegations.

“Therefore, upon these claims being received, Chubb initiated an independent external forensic accounting review,” she said. “This investigation found that the claims are without merit. We are vigorously defending these claims.”

In March this year, Howell alleged that he told Asia-Pacific regional president Marcos Gunn that the practice was obscuring Chubb’s true business performance and creating undue pressure on the property and casualty business teams.

Howell alleged Gunn told him not to “swim against the tide”. In a separate phone call, Howell alleged Chubb legal executive Mark Eggleton made a statement to him that the revenue timing practice constituted fraud.

Later that month, Howell alleged Brian Church, division president of property and casualty, asked him “to provide a story to explain Chubb’s financial performance without reference to calendarisation (timing)”.

Howell claimed that he replied with an email which explained Chubb’s true financial performance and the use of calendarisation, before going on annual leave on April 3 this year.

Howell alleged that while on annual leave and during a visit by McNamee, he was sacked unexpectedly and requested to agree that his departure from Chubb was a “mutual separation”.

In a statement, Howell said he was not willing to effectively lie.

“I was not prepared to provide false financial narratives, or have the company make investment and people decisions based on inaccurate performance measures,” he said.

“My desire was to raise and resolve my concerns internally within the Chubb Group, and I never imagined that by speaking up in support of my people and business, I would end up in this position. I am very saddened that, by speaking up and telling the truth, it has come to this.”

The company, its executives and directors are yet to file defences to Howell’s claim.

Follow the legal world’s biggest news, firms, cases, and personalities. Sign up to The Legal Brief newsletter.

 covers financial crime, courts and corporate wrongdoing for The Australian Financial Review. Send encrypted tips to maxepmason.14 on messaging platform Signal (tinyurl.com/MaxMason). Email Max at max.mason@afr.com

Nuix receives almost $1b takeover bid from US private equity firm

Intelligence software company Nuix has received an almost $1 billion takeover bid from United States-based private equity firm Haveli Investments Software Fund.

The unsolicited, non-binding offer, announced on Wednesday, proposes Haveli acquire the once scandal-plagued business for $2.75 per share, a 75 per cent premium to Nuix’s closing share price on Tuesday.

Nuix, led by chief executive John Ruthven, is urging shareholders to consider the bid. 

Nuix’s board of directors will recommend shareholders vote in favour of the bid if Haveli puts forward a binding proposal.

“The Nuix board has firm conviction in the growth opportunity available to Nuix as it transitions to a platform business,” the company said in a statement.

“At the same time, the Nuix board recognises shareholders may value the certainty of a cash offer at a significant premium,” it said.


Nuix said the proposal was not the first from Haveli, which has put forward several offers at lower prices. The first came in July this year.

The $2.75 per share offer implies an equity value of $975 million and an enterprise value of $925 million.

Nuix debuted on the ASX in late 2020, in a float that was backed by Macquarie and valued the company at $1.7 billion.

Its market capitalisation crashed within months when the company unexpectedly downgraded revenue forecasts in its prospectus, sparking an investigation by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission.

The corporate regulator ultimately sued Nuix in September 2022, alleging its then-board had misled investors. ASIC also accused directors, including former chief executive Rod Vawdrey, of breaching their duties.

Federal Court judge Scott Goodman dismissed ASIC’s entire claim against Nuix and its directors and ordered the regulator to pay costs. The watchdog has appealed the judgment related to the company, not the directors.

The company is currently worth just under $544 million. Nuix is also facing a shareholder class action in the Victorian Supreme Court over allegations that it misled the market.

Nuix chief executive John Ruthven, who was formally appointed in May, has undertaken a major restructure at the business over the past few months. This has included a change to the way it sells products, and a move to aggressively use artificial intelligence to improve efficiency.

For the year ending June 30, Nuix’s annualised contract revenue, a metric that describes the average yearly revenue from an agreement, grew 14 per cent to $260 million. The company also swung to a $16.4 million net profit.

 leads the technology team from The Australian Financial Review’s Sydney newsroom. She previously covered wagering and the business of sport. Send tips to @zoesamios.06 on encrypted messaging platform Signal or email zoesamios@proton.me. Connect with Zoe on Twitter. Email Zoe at zoe.samios@afr.com