A consulting giant refunded taxpayers over a bungle, then landed this massive deal
A year after Deloitte was forced to refund nearly $100,000 of taxpayer money over an artificial intelligence (AI) hallucination in a government report, the consulting giant has been awarded 110 fresh federal contracts.
The refund has looked more like a rounding error as the firm has secured more than $144 million in government work since the controversy broke.
Nearly 30 per cent of the post-scandal windfall came from a $41.1 million Defence contract for core budget and tax services, running from October 2026 to December 2029 with a three-year extension option to 2032.
In August 2025, it was revealed that Deloitte's report for the Employment department titled Targeted Compliance Framework Assurance Review - Final Report, contained fabricated academic citations and AI-generated errors.
Greens finance and public service spokeswoman Barbara Pocock said the firm has not faced any meaningful consequences for the blunder.
Greens finance and public service spokesperson Barbara Pocock has slammed the government for not doing enough to punish consultancies that engage in bad practice. Pictures by Sitthixay Ditthavong, Jamila Toderas and Shutterstock.
"Deloitte's AI bungle was expensive corner-cutting disguised as consultancy," Senator Pocock said.
"The scandal should have been a wake up call for the Government to consider stronger oversight of AI generated material in contracted work. And yet, since then, they have continued to dish out millions to the consultancy firm. There are no consequences for the Big 4 firms behaving badly, instead they get rewarded with new contracts into the millions."
A Defence spokesperson said the $41.1 million contract complied with procurement rules.
"Defence is delivering the Government's commitment to strengthen the APS and reduce reliance on external workforce through a disciplined program of workforce reform, commercial uplift and enhanced value for money measures," the spokesperson said.
"In keeping with standard practice, Defence will continue to monitor the ethical performance of all providers and the use of contractors to ensure that value for money and priorities are achieved, including to rebuild the public service and deliver capability."
The contract covered specialised technical financial services, including financial statements preparation and assurance, and surge support during reporting periods and support to Defence transformation activities.
The department has been working towards $5.7 billion in savings as part of the government's commitment to reduce spending on external labour and non-wage expenses.
Senator Pocock rejected the assurances and said key programs and financial work should be kept within the public service.
"The Government should not be contracting out critical core program analysis to a firm that has a track record of delivering AI slop, especially not to Defence," she said.
"We need human oversight on critical work which can and should be done by our public service."
A Canberra Times analysis found federal departments have awarded Deloitte 13 similar contracts worth about $3.8 million for reviews, reports and research since the scandal broke.
The Health department led the way, awarding $622,000 across three contracts for accommodation pricing, functional and efficiency, and financial reviews.
A Health spokesperson said the contracts were competitively tendered and determined to be value for money, with the department closely validating Deloitte's findings.
Deloitte disclosed upfront it would use AI on one review, and while a December 2025 contract lacked AI provisions, the department has since tightened terms to mandate the disclosure of AI use.
Four of the 13 review and research contracts, including deals with the Australian National Audit Office (ANAO) and Services Australia, have more than doubled in combined value through amendments, jumping from $1.04 million to $2.1 million.
The ANAO's sustainability audit contract for Snowy Hydro Limited surged more than fourfold from $168,730 to $761,990.
The ANAO said the work was being delivered on behalf of the Auditor-General, with the amendment exercising an agreed two-year extension to November 2028 for an expanded assurance scope.
Its AI transparency rules applied to both staff and contractors, requiring any AI use in audit work to be documented during planning and validation.
"Contractors must seek permission from the ANAO before any AI system or tool is used on ANAO work and must report to the ANAO on its use as part of the firm's reporting to the ANAO during the final procedures conducted near the end of each audit," the ANAO said.
A Services Australia spokesperson said the agency's contract with Deloitte was for a cost-benefit and economic analysis on the design of new myGov capabilities.
"Services Australia included specific requirements in the contract on how and where Deloitte could use AI when providing its services," the spokesperson said.
"This includes a contractual obligation on Deloitte to obtain the agency's approval before using AI, clearly identify any use in its research reports, and ensure any AI used adheres to the Research Society AI and Ethical Guidelines in Research Practice."
Senator Pocock said the government needed to redirect outsourcing funds back into the public service after an ANAO audit of the Strategic Commissioning Framework (SCF) found weaknesses in its target design and public reporting.
"Targets mean nothing without accountability, and rising spending shows there is no genuine commitment to reducing reliance on costly consultants and contractors," Senator Pocock said.
"Labor's actions don't match their promises. They say they'll reduce government reliance on consultants yet spend more money on outsourcing to them. Their SCF doesn't work."
